Data Science Group @ BCAM | Strategically Deceptive Model Deployment in Performative Prediction

Please note that this will be a short talk, from 11:30 to 12:00.​

Abstract:

Machine Learning systems are increasingly deployed in decision-making settings that shape user behaviour and, in turn, the data on which future decisions are based. Performative Prediction (PP) formalizes this feedback loop by modeling how deployed models induce distributional shifts. It studies how to learn robust and well-performing models under such dynamics. However, existing PP frameworks typically assume that the model governing these decisions is the same model observed by users, and therefore the model to which they respond

In practice, deployer institutions may instead disclose curated models, while internally relying on distinct opaque models. We introduce Decoupled Performative Prediction (DPP), a framework that explicitly models mismatches between the model governing institutional decisions and the model that shapes user behaviour. By analyzing the resulting optimization landscape, we show that DPP admits new different solutions that provably achieve lower risk for the institution than those under classical PP.

We further propose an algorithm with provable convergence guarantees under standard assumptions, demonstrating how institutions can benefit from strategically deceptive deployment when they control model disclosure and users lack countervailing power. To capture the implications of such behavior, we introduce the deception cost, a quantitative measure of the degree of deception experienced by users. We study settings in which institutions incorporate this cost into the optimization process, motivated by reputational concerns or potential user abandonment, and show that such self-imposed constraints are insufficient to protect users.

Overall, our results demonstrate that model disclosure is not merely an ethical consideration but a core technical design decision, underscoring the need for regulations that hold institutions accountable for deceptive deployment practices